A Cabaret in Hungary Asks a Horrific Question: What if Jews Vanished?

The New York Times cikke a Gólem Színház Kiválasztottak című előadásról…

BUDAPEST — What would happen if Jewish people suddenly disappeared?

That is the question asked by “The Chosen Ones,” a new production by Golem Theater which had its premiere last month in Budapest.

From left: Bence Tasnadi, Laszlo Katona (kneeling), Ivan Nadasi and Vera Sipos in “The Chosen Ones,” a production in Budapest performed by Golem Theater.CreditCredit: Eszter Gordon

Golem, a Jewish theater company, describes the show as a political cabaret, with topical jokes and live music, that aims to lampoon hatred using dark humor. On opening night last month, a handful of players performed on a white revolving stage set against a shimmering curtain.

An early number proclaimed, “Now the bank, the factory and the lawyer’s office will close/Because the you-know-whos are gone, but we don’t know where.”

The evening unfolded in a succession of sketches and musical numbers presenting a cross-section of Hungarian society as they reacted to the news of the missing people: an orchestra suddenly lacking most of its players; a family eating a meal without the grandmother; a middle-class household discovering that the neighbors have vanished.

Despite the absences, the players carried on. They sang and danced, swapping roles and guises.

But in this show, the audience of about 150 rarely laughed.

“I was very glad to see that one can feel sadness in a cabaret,” said the production’s director, Andras Borgula, who studied theater in Israel and founded Golem Theater in Budapest in 2005. “Our intention wasn’t to make a play about anti-Semitism, but about hatred in general, of which anti-Semitism is just one type,” he added.

Hatred has been high on the agenda in Hungary since Prime Minister Viktor Orban, who began a third consecutive term in office this year, set out to establish an “illiberal democracy” in the country. Government-funded billboard campaigns, as well as television, radio and online advertisements, have presented threatening messages about migrants, the European Union and the Hungarian-born Jewish financier and philanthropist George Soros.

The prominence of hate speech in the country has caused concern internationally, and alarmed many in Hungary, a country which lost over half a million Jews in World War II and where anti-Semitism has been endemic throughout modern history.

When billboards appeared across the country last summer, showing a smiling Mr. Soros with the line, “Don’t let Soros have the last laugh,” anti-Semitic graffiti soon appeared on many of them. Andras Heisler, leader of the Federation of Hungarian Jewish Communities, addressed an open letter to Mr. Orban at the time: “This campaign, while not openly anti-Semitic, clearly has the potential to ignite uncontrolled emotions, including anti-Semitism,” he wrote, calling for an end to “this bad dream.”

In a phone interview this week, Mr. Heisler said that there was more public animosity in Hungary toward the Roma minority and refugees than toward Jews. But, he said, “our historical experiences suggest that it is never good to have strong hatred in a country.”

As the audience entered the venue for “The Chosen Ones,” the director and some assistants greeted them from a stand, like agents conducting a survey. They sized up each person and categorized them in groups including “cultural Jew,” “Soros Jew” or “self-hating Jew” — labels taken from public speech and online forums in Hungary. Later, a young woman performed a musical litany of hate against everyone, across the whole political and social spectrum. “Doesn’t matter why, doesn’t matter who, everyone’s a filthy something,” she sang.

Political cabaret is a popular genre in Hungary with a long tradition that survived through the country’s Communist dictatorship. Some characters in “The Chosen Ones” suggest real-life figures — one is “the prime minister,” for example — others bring to mind archetypes, such as “liberal protester.”

Mr. Borgula said the anti-Semitic slurs heard onstage “fly around in public life so much that we need to talk about them,” adding, “This is therapy, we need to laugh at it.” And plays that deal with current events are more popular with audiences than other productions in Golem Theater’s repertoire, he said.

Read more…


  • Zsidónak lenni nem kerül pénzbe, a zsidó média viszont nincs ingyen.

    Támogasd te is Magyarország egyik legolvasottabb zsidó lapját, a Kibic Magazint!